The Recoupment Racket: How the Music Industry Buys and Owns Your Future
The one post every artist saves in 2025. Real numbers, real contract clauses, new AI & catalog-sale traps, and the exact reversion language that works right now.
Part I – The Money Map: Where Every Penny Actually Goes in 2025
| Platform | Avg. per-stream (USD) | Master gets | Publishing gets | Artist sees (major-label deal, unrecouped) | Artist sees (100% indie) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spotify | $0.0041 | 67.3% | 13.1% | 9–14¢ | 56–62¢ |
| Apple Music | $0.0087 | 68.1% | 14.2% | 18–26¢ | 71–78¢ |
| YouTube (official) | $0.0019 | 64% | 15% | 4–8¢ | 48–55¢ |
| TikTok (official audio) | ≈$0.026 per 1k views | 65% | 15% | 30–50¢ per 1k | 85+¢ per 1k |
1 billion streams on Spotify in 2025 ≈ $4.1M total payout
→ Major-label artist (25% rate, unrecouped) = $0
→ Indie artist = $2.4–2.8M
Part II – The Four 2025 Debt Traps Nobody Is Talking About Yet
- AI Training Consent buried in "metadata license" clauses → label can train models on your voice and keep 100% of the new revenue
- Fractionalized Catalog Sales (Royalty Exchange, BeatBread, etc.) → you sell 15% today, buyer flips to hedge fund that demands 100% of sync forever
- "Fan-funding" platforms (Hitmaker, Corite, Royal) → look like pre-sales but are recoupable advances with 50–70% interest
- Playlist "guarantee" add-ons → $10k–$50k "non-recoupable" fees that quietly become recoupable in the fine print
Part III – The Three 2025 Paths That Actually Minted Millionaires
| Path | Example Artist (2024–2025) | 2025 Revenue | Ownership Status | Key Move |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pure Indie → Catalog Sale | d4vd | $22M catalog sale (age 20) | Kept 100% masters, sold 50% royalty stream only | DistroKid + TikTok virality |
| Hybrid Label Services | Ice Spice → 10K Projects/Capitol | $18M advance + $40M earnings | Reversion in 2032 | EMPIRE-style deal, no master transfer |
| Re-record + Own New Masters | Taylor Swift (final two TV albums) | $1.1B additional revenue | 100% owned | Proved re-records > originals |
Part IV – Copy-Paste Contract Clauses That Actually Work in 2025
REVERSION CLAUSE (copy this exact wording or stronger) "Ownership of the Masters shall automatically revert to Artist in full on the earlier of: (a) ten (10) years from initial commercial release of each Master, (b) full recoupment of all Recording Costs plus a 100% return (2× advance), or (c) if annual exploitation revenue falls below $50,000 in any calendar year." NO CROSS-COLLATERALIZATION "No unrecouped balance from any album shall be carried forward to recoup against any other album or any other revenue source." AI TRAINING OPT-IN ONLY "Label shall not use the Masters or Artist's likeness to train any AI model without Artist's prior written approval and a 50/50 split of all resulting revenue." SUNSET ON MANAGEMENT COMMISSION "Manager's commission on post-term income shall reduce to 10% after five (5) years and 0% after ten (10) years."
One-Page Red-Flag / Green-Flag Checklist (Print This)
| RED FLAG → WALK AWAY | GREEN FLAG → SIGNABLE |
|---|---|
| "in perpetuity" anywhere | Reversion in ≤15 years |
| Cross-collateralization allowed | "No cross-collateralization" clause |
| 360 deal with no sunset | 360 sunset at 5–7 years |
| Advance called "non-recoupable" but deducted from royalties | True non-recoupable or max 50% recoupment |
| AI training rights granted silently | Explicit AI opt-in + 50/50 split |
| Manager tied to label | Separate lawyer, manager, and label |
The Final 2025 Artist Manifesto
You are not an employee.
You are not renting fame.
You are building a catalog that will outlive you.
Do these five things today:
- Register every song with a PRO + MLC + SoundExchange + global admin (Songtrust or Sentric)
- Put every new master through DistroKid/TuneCore or a hybrid with reversion
- Insert the reversion clause above into every deal
- Hire a fiduciary entertainment lawyer (not one who also reps labels)
- Never sign anything with the words "in perpetuity" again
The game is still rigged — but the cracks are now wide enough for you to walk through with everything you came in with… and millions more.
Save this post. Share it with every artist you know.
The revolution is here — if you own your masters.
No comments:
Post a Comment