Posts
FLORIDA STATE'S SECOND BITE
Why Project Osceola 2.0 Will Succeed Where The First Failed—
And Why FSU's LLC + PE Announcement Is Coming By June 2026
THE PREDICTION
Florida State University will announce LLC formation with private equity partnership by June 30, 2026.
The firm will likely be Sixth Street (returning after 2024 talks ended) or a new entrant capitalizing on the now-clear regulatory landscape. The structure will mirror Utah's Brands & Entertainment model with $300-500M in combined capital.
This prediction is being made January 1, 2026. It is specific, falsifiable, and will be tracked publicly.
Why This Isn't Speculation
```Florida State tried to bring in private equity once before. Between 2022 and 2024, in talks code-named "Project Osceola," FSU worked with JPMorgan Chase, Sixth Street, and Arctos Partners on a deal that would have brought hundreds of millions in capital to Seminoles athletics.
The talks were advanced. One source told Sportico the parties "had the structure of a deal in place." Sixth Street's due diligence was comprehensive. Term sheets were exchanged. A "NewCo" entity was designed to house FSU's commercial rights.
And then in December 2024, it ended. Mutually. No deal.
Why did it fail? Two points of uncertainty proved insurmountable:
- FSU's ACC lawsuit (outcome unknown, exit fee potentially $572M)
- House v. NCAA settlement (terms unclear, revenue-sharing obligations uncertain)
Private equity firms don't invest into uncertainty. The legal risk was too high. The financial obligations were too unclear. Project Osceola died not because the model was wrong, but because the conditions weren't right.
Part I: What Changed — The Barriers Are Gone
```Barrier #1 Removed: The ACC Settlement (March 2025)
On March 31, 2025, Florida State and Clemson reached a settlement with the ACC that fundamentally changed the economics of conference membership.
- Viewership-based revenue distribution: 60% of TV money distributed by ratings (rewards FSU's high viewership)
- Declining exit fees: $18M reduction per year through 2029-30, then drops to $75M by 2030
- Media rights retained on exit: After paying exit fee, schools keep their media rights (previously grant of rights extended through 2036)
- All lawsuits dropped: Clean slate, no pending litigation
What this means for PE:
- Exit path is now clear and financially manageable
- No legal uncertainty about $500M+ exit fee lawsuit
- Timeline is defined (can exit by 2030 for $75M + declining amounts if earlier)
- Performance-based revenue creates upside (FSU gets more money for high ratings)
Barrier #2 Removed: House Settlement (June 2025)
On June 7, 2025, the House v. NCAA settlement was approved, creating clarity on revenue-sharing obligations.
- Revenue-sharing cap: $20.5M for 2025-26 (22% of average Power 4 revenue)
- Annual increases: 4% minimum per year (reaches $32.9M by 2034-35)
- Opt-in model: Schools choose whether to participate
- No employment relationship: Athletes compensated but not deemed employees (for now)
What this means for PE:
- Financial obligations are now quantified and predictable
- Can model returns with actual numbers ($20.5M annual cost, growing 4%)
- No uncertainty about "how much will this cost?"
- Legal framework exists (imperfect, but exists)
Part II: The Financial Crisis Is Worse, Not Better
```Here's the brutal reality: FSU's financial situation hasn't improved since Project Osceola talks ended. It's gotten worse.
The Numbers
FY 2023 (Latest Complete Data):
• Revenue: $170M
• Expenses: $172M
• Deficit: $2.5M
• Total athletic debt: $119M+ (up from $21M in 2019)
• Annual debt service: $11M+
FY 2024 (Reported):
• Revenue: ~$195M (estimated, includes one-time items)
• Expenses: Similar
• Surplus: $15.2M (primarily from donor surge, not sustainable)
• Additional bonds issued: $326.6M (for stadium renovation + new facility)
• Total debt now: $445M+ (old debt + new bonds)
FY 2026 (Projected WITH Revenue Sharing):
• Revenue: ~$190-200M (assuming viewership-based ACC bump)
• NEW Expenses:
→ Revenue sharing: $20.5M
→ Expanded scholarships: ~$2M
→ Enhanced compliance: ~$1M
• Previous expenses: ~$190M
• Debt service (with new bonds): ~$25M annually
• Total expenses: $238M+
• Projected annual deficit: $40-50M
Read that again: $40-50M annual structural deficit starting in FY2026.
The Debt Trap
FSU's total athletic-related debt exploded from $21M (2019) to $445M+ (2025). This happened because:
- $326.6M in new bonds (May 2024): Stadium renovation + new football facility
- $111M existing bonds: Previous facility debt still outstanding
- Additional obligations: Various other liabilities
All of this debt is backed by athletic department revenue — conference payouts, ticket sales, donations, sponsorships. If revenue declines or doesn't grow as projected, FSU has a crisis.
"The above-referenced factors, collectively or individually, could result in a material change to FSU's on-field performance and/or the Pledged Revenues over the life of the Series 2024A&B Bonds. Buyers of the Series 2024A&B Bonds should take into consideration these developments, and other potential risk factors related to collegiate athletics, when deciding whether to purchase the Series 2024A&B Bonds."
Translation: "We might not be able to pay you back. This is risky." That's what you say when your financial model is fragile.
Where Can FSU Cut $40-50M?
Traditional solutions don't work:
| Option | Reality |
|---|---|
| Cut Olympic Sports | Could save $10-15M max. Creates Title IX violations, massive alumni backlash, still leaves $25-35M gap. |
| Increase Donations | Donors already maxed out funding NIL collectives separately. The $15.2M FY2024 "surplus" was donor surge that's not sustainable annually. |
| University Subsidy | FSU is public university. Florida legislature unlikely to approve $40M+ annual subsidy to athletics while academic programs face cuts. |
| Cut Football Spending | Impossible. Already behind SEC/Big Ten competitors. Cutting football budget means guaranteed losing, which destroys revenue. |
| Wait for ACC Payout Increase | ACC's new deal helps but doesn't close gap. Even with viewership-based distribution, FSU getting maybe $50-55M vs. SEC/Big Ten schools getting $70-80M+. |
None of these work. FSU faces a permanent structural deficit that traditional athletic department financial models cannot solve.
Part III: Why PE Will Return (And Why FSU Needs Them)
```What PE Brings That FSU Desperately Needs
1. Immediate Capital ($300-500M)
- Covers revenue-sharing obligations for multiple years
- Provides working capital buffer
- Funds additional facility/brand investments
- Can be used to pay down existing debt (reducing annual debt service)
2. Professional Revenue Optimization
- Sixth Street owns Legends Hospitality (premium seating/events expert)
- Experience monetizing sports IP globally
- Data-driven pricing and inventory management
- Projected: 15-20% revenue growth through optimization
3. Liability Protection Through LLC Structure
- Separate legal entity shields university from athletic department liabilities
- Employment lawsuits, Title IX challenges, debt defaults — all contained in LLC
- University's academic mission and endowment protected
4. Operational Flexibility
- LLC can move faster than university bureaucracy
- Can pursue partnerships, deals, ventures that universities can't
- Can restructure operations without board of trustees approval for every decision
Why Sixth Street (Or Similar) Returns
The deal they walked away from in December 2024 makes sense now:
What Sixth Street Gets:
- Minority equity stake in "FSU Brands LLC" (or similar entity)
- Board representation (oversight, not control)
- Percentage of annual revenue from commercial operations
- Exit after 5-7 years at premium to investment
- Exclusive or semi-exclusive IP license for certain commercial uses
What FSU Gets:
- $300-500M capital injection (est.)
- Professional sports business management (Legends integration)
- Revenue optimization expertise
- Liability firewall through LLC structure
- Maintains majority control
- Path to future conference realignment funded
The Return Calculation
Let's model why PE wants this deal:
Investment: $350M (equity + donor equity facilitation)
Equity stake: 30-35% of FSU Brands LLC
Annual revenue share: 10-12% of commercial revenue
FSU Current Commercial Revenue: ~$120M annually
(Tickets, sponsorships, media rights, licensing, premium seating)
5-Year Projection with Professional Management:
• Year 1: $120M → $140M (immediate optimization, Legends integration)
• Year 2: $140M → $161M (15% growth)
• Year 3: $161M → $185M
• Year 4: $185M → $213M
• Year 5: $213M → $245M
Sixth Street's Annual Distributions (12% of revenue):
• 5-year total: ~$110M
Exit Valuation (Year 7, FSU buys back stake):
• FSU Brands LLC valued at $1.2B (7x EBITDA)
• Sixth Street's 30% stake: $360M
Total Return:
• Distributions: $110M
• Exit proceeds: $360M
• Total: $470M on $350M investment
• IRR: ~16-18% (target PE return)
This is a good deal for both sides. FSU gets the capital and expertise it desperately needs. Sixth Street gets attractive returns from a premium sports brand.
```Part IV: The Locomotive Pattern At FSU
```Let's apply the framework from our comprehensive series on college athletics financialization.
FSU Is The Big Three
Florida State is trapped in traditional athletic department thinking:
- Identity: "We are elite program that belongs in elite conference" — but identity doesn't pay bills
- Metrics: Measuring success by wins, not by capital efficiency or revenue optimization
- Customer relationship: Selling to fans and donors using amateur athletics narrative
- Sunk costs: $445M in facility debt optimized for old model, now becoming anchor
- Technical superiority delusion: "Better facilities and coaching will save us" — but that's not the game anymore
PE Firms Are EMD
Private equity brings what EMD brought to locomotives:
- Financing: GMAC provided capital for locomotives; PE provides capital for athletics
- Professional management: EMD hired business operators; PE brings Legends/sports business pros
- Standardization: EMD standardized products; PE standardizes revenue operations
- Service networks: EMD built ongoing relationships; PE creates ongoing value optimization
- Selling to different customer: EMD sold to CFOs; PE sells to investors/returns-focused stakeholders
Why FSU Can't Wait
The locomotive companies had 30+ years to adapt. They failed anyway. FSU has maybe 2-3 years before financial crisis becomes terminal:
2026: First year of $20.5M revenue sharing. $40M+ deficit. Covered by donor surge (not sustainable).
2027: Revenue sharing increases to $21.3M. Deficit grows to $45M+. Donors tapped out. Start cutting Olympic sports.
2028: Revenue sharing $22.2M. Deficit $50M+. Major Olympic sports cuts. Bond covenant violations possible.
2029: Revenue sharing $23.1M. Can't service debt. Either default or emergency university subsidy.
2030: Bankruptcy or forced conference realignment to lower-revenue league just to survive.
This is the path FSU is on without structural change. Traditional athletic department cannot sustain elite program in new financial environment.
```Part V: The Prediction — Why Q1-Q2 2026
```Why The Timing Is Now
1. Both Barriers Resolved (March + June 2025)
PE firms can now invest with clarity. Six months is reasonable time to restart talks, conduct updated diligence, finalize terms.
2. FY2026 Budget Reality Hitting
FSU is living the $40M+ deficit in real-time right now. This isn't theoretical future problem — it's immediate crisis demanding immediate solution.
3. Competitive Pressure Mounting
Kentucky formed Champions Blue (April 2025). Utah partnered with Otro (December 2025). FSU is now third, not first. Competitive disadvantage grows with each month of delay.
4. Conference Realignment Window
ACC exit fees decline $18M per year through 2029-30. If FSU wants to leave for SEC/Big Ten by 2028-29 (optimal timing), they need capital secured NOW to fund exit fee + maintain competitiveness during transition.
5. Donor/Political Environment
Florida's political leadership and FSU's donor base are increasingly frustrated with ACC financial gap. Support for bold action (LLC + PE) is probably at peak. Delay risks losing this political/donor alignment.
The Specific Prediction
WHAT WILL BE ANNOUNCED
By June 30, 2026, Florida State will announce:
- Formation of for-profit LLC (likely "FSU Brands LLC" or "Seminole Sports LLC")
- Partnership with PE firm (60% probability: Sixth Street returns; 40%: new firm enters)
- Total capital: $300-500M (PE equity + donor equity)
- Commercial operations move to LLC; competition stays with university
- Professional sports business executives join board/management
Most likely announcement window: March-May 2026
(Gives time for Q1 due diligence, allows announcement before FY2027 budget cycle)
What To Watch
Signals FSU Is Moving:
- FSU administrators meeting with PE firms (might not be public but watch for hints)
- JPMorgan Chase engagement resumes (they facilitated Project Osceola)
- Quiet discussions with Florida Board of Governors (need approval for LLC)
- Increased rhetoric about "structural solutions" to financial challenges
- Donor communications about "new model" or "transformational approach"
What Would Delay/Prevent It:
- IRS issues guidance explicitly prohibiting athletic LLCs (unlikely but possible)
- Florida legislature passes law blocking public universities from forming for-profit LLCs (political risk)
- PE firms collectively decide college athletics too risky post-Utah (market risk)
- FSU miraculously solves $40M deficit through traditional means (fantasy)
Part VI: What It Means When FSU Goes
```FSU Is The Proof Of Concept
Kentucky pioneered the LLC structure. Utah proved PE partnerships work. But Florida State will be the validation that this is the new model for elite college athletics.
Why FSU matters more:
- Brand power: FSU is top-10 national brand, bigger than Kentucky/Utah
- Media attention: FSU's ACC lawsuit made them the face of conference realignment chaos
- Geographic significance: Florida recruiting/market critical to college football
- Financial transparency: As public university, FSU's deal terms will be more visible than private schools
The Domino Effect
When FSU announces LLC + PE partnership, expect immediate follow-on announcements:
Within 30 days: Clemson announces similar structure (they're in same boat as FSU)
Within 60 days: 2-3 additional ACC schools announce exploration (UNC, Miami, Virginia Tech candidates)
Within 90 days: First Big 12 school announces (competitive pressure from ACC moves)
By end of 2026: 8-12 total schools operating as LLCs with PE backing
FSU won't be the last. They'll be the proof that the model works at top-tier programs. That's when the transformation accelerates from "early adopters" to "new normal."
What Dies When FSU Goes LLC
Florida State's move will kill several things permanently:
- The amateur athletics fiction: Can't pretend it's educational when PE firms own equity
- The "student-athlete" narrative: Athletes in LLC structures are quasi-employees regardless of legal designation
- University control of athletics: Board representation from PE means external influence on decisions
- Traditional donor model: Donors become investors expecting returns, not philanthropists supporting education
- ACC as viable conference: FSU + Clemson in LLCs accelerates conference instability/collapse
- NCAA governance legitimacy: When elite programs are for-profit LLCs, NCAA rules become meaningless
Part VII: Why I'm Making This Prediction Publicly
```This isn't idle speculation or hot-take content farming. This is pattern completion based on documented evidence and established frameworks.
What I'm Risking
If I'm wrong (FSU doesn't announce by June 30, 2026):
- This analysis looks foolish
- My credibility on college athletics takes hit
- The locomotive pattern framework is questioned
- I have to publicly acknowledge the miss and analyze why
If I'm right (FSU announces as predicted):
- This analysis becomes THE reference for how FSU got there
- The locomotive pattern framework is validated
- Future predictions gain credibility
- I become THE authority who called it before anyone else
The Evidence Supporting This Prediction
This isn't a guess. It's based on:
- Project Osceola happened (2022-2024) — Advanced talks with Sixth Street, JPMorgan, Arctos
- Deal structure was developed — "NewCo" entity designed, terms discussed
- Talks ended December 2024 due to legal uncertainty (ACC lawsuit + House settlement)
- Both barriers resolved (March + June 2025) — Conditions that killed deal are now gone
- FSU's financial crisis is worse — $40-50M structural deficit starting FY2026
- Kentucky and Utah proved model works — LLC + PE is now validated approach
- FSU has no alternative solution — Traditional methods cannot close $40M+ annual gap
- Competitive pressure is acute — Every month without PE partnership is lost ground vs. competitors
Given these facts, FSU returning to PE isn't speculation—it's the logical, almost inevitable outcome. The only question is timing, and Q1-Q2 2026 is the sweet spot between "deal takes time" and "crisis demands urgency."
How I'll Track This
I will update this analysis quarterly with:
- Any FSU developments related to LLC formation or PE discussions
- Financial data as it becomes available
- Signals being tracked (are they appearing or not?)
- Adjustments to prediction if new evidence emerges
- Honest assessment if prediction proves wrong
Next update: March 31, 2026 (will assess whether Q1 announcement happened or Q2 still possible)
```The Second Bite
```Florida State tried once to bring in private equity. The conditions weren't right. The deal died.
Now the conditions are perfect:
- Legal clarity exists (ACC settlement + House settlement)
- Financial crisis is acute ($40M+ annual deficit)
- Proven model exists (Kentucky + Utah demonstrated it works)
- PE firms have validated the space (Otro Capital's success)
- No alternative solutions exist (traditional methods insufficient)
- Competitive pressure is maximum (every delay costs ground)
The only rational response is to revive Project Osceola with updated terms reflecting the new legal/financial landscape.
This isn't about whether FSU should do this. This is about whether they will do this. And based on the evidence, financial reality, and established pattern: they will.
When Florida State announces their LLC formation with PE partnership sometime between January and June 2026, remember: you read it here first. With the full reasoning. With the evidence. With the prediction on the record.
And when it happens, it won't be a surprise. It will be pattern completion.
```The Prediction Is On Record
```Florida State will announce LLC formation with private equity partnership by June 30, 2026.
Most likely: March-May 2026
Most likely partner: Sixth Street (returning) or new PE firm
Capital: $300-500M
Structure: Mirrors Utah Brands & Entertainment model
This prediction was made January 1, 2026
It is specific, falsifiable, and will be tracked publicly
When it happens, you saw it here first.
Analysis by Randy T Gipe
Part of "The Locomotive Lens" series on business model disruption
Created through human-AI collaboration
Published January 2026
Read the full college athletics financialization series:
"The Athletic LLC Playbook: How College Football Is Becoming Private Equity"
33,000+ words | Evidence-based | Updated quarterly
