Music Publishing: Royalties, Contracts, and the Royalty Maze (Part II)

I. The Royalty Maze

Royalties are the lifeblood of music, but the system is riddled with complexity. A single track can generate multiple revenue streams, each controlled by a different entity:

• Mechanical Royalties: paid for reproduction of music (CD, vinyl, digital downloads).
• Performance Royalties: for public performance on radio, live shows, or streaming.
• Synchronization (Sync) Royalties: for use in TV, film, or ads.
• Digital Distribution: streaming platforms allocate payouts per play, often fractions of a cent.

Every intermediary – label, publisher, collection society, manager – claims a slice, leaving the artist with a small fraction.

II. Hidden Fees and Accounting Tricks

The opaque nature of contracts often hides additional deductions:

• Administration Fees: publishers take a percentage for bookkeeping.
• Recoupable Expenses: studio costs, marketing, and advances are recouped before royalties.
• Cross-Collateralization: revenue from one album offsets losses from another.

This means an artist might sell millions of streams but see delayed or reduced payments.

III. Data Black Holes and Streaming Revenue

Streaming services report plays, but the underlying revenue allocation is hidden. Key issues include:

• Aggregated payouts prevent granular understanding of revenue.
• Latency of reporting makes it impossible for artists to audit in real-time.
• Algorithms determining playlist placement heavily influence income yet are proprietary.

Collectively, this strengthens intermediaries’ control while artists remain in the dark.

IV. Managerial Leverage

Managers often negotiate deals that benefit themselves as much as or more than their clients:

• Standard 15–20% commission on gross earnings.
• Power to approve or block collaborations, placements, or tours.
• Access to artist data enables strategic control over career trajectory.

Combined with label and publisher structures, this creates a tightly controlled system where the artist has limited leverage.

V. Legal and Industry Gaps

Many artists are unaware of legal mechanisms to protect themselves:

• Songwriter rights can revert, but clauses often delay this by decades.
• Contracts rarely include real-time transparency or audit clauses.
• Emerging technologies like blockchain and smart contracts are underutilized.

Without innovation, the corporate machine continues unchallenged.

VI. Cracks in the Machine

Independent artists are beginning to leverage digital tools:

• Direct-to-fan platforms bypass traditional intermediaries.
• Smart contracts can automatically distribute royalties fairly.
• Blockchain offers verifiable accounting and ownership tracking.

These emerging solutions hint at the possibility of breaking the Wall and returning power to creators.

👉 Share Post