THE WATER MACHINE: Who Gets Water in America — and Who Hauls It in Drums
"Jackson's crisis did not happen overnight. It was decades in the making — and the state agency responsible for oversight chose, repeatedly, not to act on what it documented."
— EPA Office of Inspector General Report, 2024 (paraphrased finding)
Post 1: The River That Isn't There — The 1922 Compact. 9 million acre-feet of fiction.
Post 2: $200 A Year — BlueTriton/Nestlé. 81,020 objections. Nine reform bills. None passed.
Post 3: The Drum Haulers — Navajo Nation. 1868 treaty. 72× cost. Supreme Court: not our problem.
Post 4: The GM Test — Flint. Engine parts protected October 2014. Children's blood confirmed September 2015.
Post 5: Seven Years Hidden — Jackson. MSDH knew in 2015. City lost water in 2022. ← YOU ARE HERE
Post 6: The $14 Million River — Greenstone. Queen Creek. First private Colorado River sale.
Post 7: The $100 Million Position — Water Asset Management. La Paz County. The playbook at scale.
Post 8: The Complete Architecture — PE firms, utility mergers, tribal exclusion, and the script.
Jackson, Mississippi is the capital of the state. It is 83% Black. Twenty-five percent of its residents live below the poverty line. Its water system — built for a city of 200,000, now serving under 150,000 after decades of population loss — had been in documented violation of the Safe Drinking Water Act repeatedly since at least 2018. A 2020 federal consent order was already in place when the system collapsed in August 2022. The Mississippi State Department of Health had documented lead issues as early as 2015 — seven years before the crisis — according to a 2024 EPA Office of Inspector General report that found MSDH failed to timely report violations to the EPA, failed to adequately document systemic problems, and failed to communicate effectively with the city and federal regulators. When Pearl River flooding overwhelmed the already-failing O.B. Curtis Water Treatment Plant in late August 2022, 150,000 residents lost safe running water for weeks. The National Guard delivered bottled water. Hospitals, schools, and businesses scrambled. The state declared an emergency. Federal emergency was declared. And the evidence that the system was heading toward exactly this failure had been in the Mississippi State Department of Health's own records for seven years. Hidden — not by accident, but by the systematic failure of a state regulatory agency to do what it was required to do: report what it found.
The Timeline of Hidden Evidence
```
As early as 2015
⚫ MSDH Documents Lead Issues — Does Not Report to EPA
The Mississippi State Department of Health, responsible for oversight of the Jackson water system under the Safe Drinking Water Act, documents lead-related issues in the Jackson system. Per the 2024 EPA OIG report, MSDH fails to timely report these findings to the EPA as required. The clock on seven years of silence starts here.
2018 onward
⚫ Repeated Safe Drinking Water Act Violations — Documented but Obscured
Jackson's water system violates federal Safe Drinking Water Act standards repeatedly beginning at least in 2018. Boil-water advisories become routine. Pipe breaks multiply. Non-revenue water loss — water that enters the system and leaks before reaching customers — exceeds 50% in some reported periods. The system is losing more water than it delivers. MSDH documentation of these violations exists. Reporting to EPA: inadequate.
February 2020
Federal Consent Order — System Already Failing
The EPA and Department of Justice issue a federal consent order requiring Jackson to address its water system's chronic violations. The consent order acknowledges the severity of the system's deficiencies. Required fixes: begin immediately. Federal oversight: now formally engaged. The system continues to deteriorate. Funding for repairs: limited. State assistance: minimal.
February 2021
🔴 Winter Storm — First Major Failure
A severe winter storm overwhelms the already-fragile Jackson water system. Widespread outages. Thousands of residents without water for days. Boil-water advisories. The 2022 crisis is previewed here — a smaller-scale version of exactly what will happen 18 months later. The warning: real, documented, not acted upon at the scale required.
Late August 2022
🔴 PEARL RIVER FLOODING — CATASTROPHIC FAILURE
Heavy storms cause the Pearl River to crest near 35 feet. Flooding inundates the O.B. Curtis Water Treatment Plant — already operating on backup pumps following prior failures. Treatment halts. Pumps fail. Water pressure collapses across the system. 150,000 residents — in a majority-Black city with 25% poverty — have no safe running water. Cannot drink it. Cannot flush. Cannot wash hands. Hospitals, schools, and businesses shut down or scramble for alternatives.
August 29–30, 2022
State and Federal Emergencies Declared
Governor Tate Reeves declares a state of emergency. National Guard deployed to distribute bottled water and operate water buffalo trucks. Millions of water bottles distributed. The emergency that the 2015 MSDH records were supposed to prevent — and that the 2020 consent order was supposed to address — is now national news.
September–November 2022
Partial Restoration — Federal Intervention
Water pressure partially restored by September 5. Boil-water advisory lifted September 15 after system stabilization. EPA declares water safe October 31. State emergency ends November 22. Federal court enters an Interim Stipulated Order — appointing Ted Henifin as third-party interim manager and transitioning operations to JXN Water, a nonprofit entity. The system that failed is now under federal court oversight.
2024
🔴 EPA OIG REPORT — THE SEVEN YEARS CONFIRMED
The EPA Office of Inspector General releases its report on the Jackson crisis. Finding: MSDH failed to timely report violations to EPA — including lead issues documented as early as 2015. Failed to adequately document systemic problems including frequent line breaks and recurring boil-water notices. Failed to communicate effectively with the city and EPA. The report confirms what the timeline suggested: the evidence of impending failure had been in state records for seven years. The regulatory mechanism designed to catch it — MSDH oversight — had failed to trigger the federal response that might have prevented the 2022 collapse.
```
🔥 Smoking Gun #1
The 2024 EPA OIG Report: MSDH Documented Lead Issues in 2015 and Did Not Report Them — For Seven Years
The 2024 EPA Office of Inspector General report is the primary source document that makes the Jackson crisis more than a story about aging infrastructure. It is the document that establishes the mechanism of failure: not just a deteriorating system, but a state regulatory agency that repeatedly chose not to do what federal law required it to do.
What MSDH was required to do: Under the Safe Drinking Water Act, state primacy agencies — like MSDH — are required to report violations to the EPA, document systemic problems, and take enforcement action when systems fail to comply. These are not discretionary functions. They are legal obligations.
What MSDH did instead: Failed to timely report violations. Failed to adequately document systemic issues including frequent line breaks and recurring boil-water notices. Failed to communicate effectively with the city and the EPA. The OIG report found these failures obscured the severity of Jackson's crisis from federal regulators who might have intervened earlier.
The 2015 lead documentation is the most consequential finding. Flint's crisis became national news in late 2015 when lead contamination was confirmed. MSDH was documenting lead issues in Jackson the same year — and not reporting them. The pattern that defined Flint — evidence documented, minimized, not acted upon — was simultaneously playing out in Jackson, with seven additional years to accumulate before the 2022 collapse made it undeniable.
VERDICT: The state agency responsible for protecting 150,000 Jackson residents documented lead issues in 2015 and failed to report them as required by federal law. Seven years later, the system collapsed. The 2024 EPA OIG report confirmed the failure was not infrastructure alone — it was regulatory silence in the face of documented evidence. The crisis was preventable. The prevention mechanism existed. The mechanism failed.
The Numbers That Built the Crisis
JACKSON, MISSISSIPPI WATER CRISIS — CONFIRMED FIGURES
Jackson population~150,000–160,000
Racial composition83% Black
Poverty rate~25%
MSDH first documents lead issuesAs early as 2015
Safe Drinking Water Act violations beginAt least 2018
Federal consent order issuedFebruary 2020
Winter storm failure (preview crisis)February 2021
2022 catastrophic failure dateLate August 2022
Residents without safe water~150,000–180,000
Duration of acute crisis~6–7 weeks at peak severity
Non-revenue water loss (leaks)50%+ in some periods
Third-party interim manager appointedTed Henifin / JXN Water
Leak detection reduced demand by~25–27% after intervention
EPA OIG report finding year2024
Gap: first documented lead issues → crisis7 years
Current water status (early 2026)Operationally stable, meets standards
Governance status (early 2026)Still under federal court oversight
"We've been complaining about this water for years. Nobody listened until it stopped coming out of the tap."
— Jackson resident, August 2022, to Associated Press
🔥 Smoking Gun #2
The System Lost More Water to Leaks Than It Delivered — For Years. The State Knew. The Fix Cost Less Than the Crisis.
Jackson's water system was, by multiple accounts, losing more than 50% of its water to leaks before reaching customers in some periods. Pipes so old and deteriorated that water entered the distribution system, leaked into the ground, and never arrived at a tap.
The interim manager appointed after the 2022 crisis — Ted Henifin and the JXN Water team — implemented leak detection and repair as a priority. The result: demand reduced by approximately 25–27% through leak fixes alone. Water that had been invisibly escaping the system was retained. The system stabilized — not by building new infrastructure, but by fixing what was already leaking.
What this means: The leaks that were draining the system and straining the treatment plant's capacity were documented, known, and fixable. The post-crisis intervention proved it. The pre-crisis regulatory oversight — MSDH — had documented systemic problems including frequent line breaks since at least 2018. The documentation existed. The reporting to EPA that might have triggered earlier federal intervention: absent.
The cost comparison: The 2020 consent order required immediate fixes. Federal infrastructure funding was potentially available through programs like the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (2021). The crisis response — National Guard deployment, millions of water bottles, federal emergency, three-party court intervention — cost far more than earlier infrastructure investment would have. The state chose regulatory silence over repair. 150,000 residents paid the cost of that choice in August 2022.
VERDICT: The system was losing half its water to leaks. Post-crisis repairs reduced demand 25–27% through leak fixes alone. MSDH had documented the systemic problems. The reporting mechanism that would have triggered federal intervention earlier: failed. The cost of silence exceeded the cost of repair — measured in money, in weeks without water, and in the sustained damage to a majority-Black community that had been raising alarms for years before anyone with authority acted.
The Pattern Across Five Posts
Posts 1 through 5 have now documented five distinct water failures across five different mechanisms. Put them side by side and the pattern is not subtle.
THE WATER MACHINE — WHO BEARS THE COST (Posts 1–5)
Post 1
Colorado River Basin: 1922 Compact over-allocated a river at twice its sustainable yield. The states that got there first in 1922 are first in line when the river runs short. Tribes excluded from the room where the allocation happened.
Post 2
Michigan aquifer: BlueTriton extracts 210M gallons/year for under $1,000. 80,945 objections legally irrelevant. Nine reform bills killed. Corporate extraction protected by the design of the permitting system.
Post 3
Navajo Nation: Senior 1868 treaty rights. Excluded from 1922 Compact. 30–40% of homes without running water in 2026. Supreme Court: no federal duty to deliver. Settlement: unratified in Congress.
Post 4
Flint, MI: Majority-Black, 40% poverty. Emergency manager switches water source to save $5M/year. No corrosion control. GM's engine parts protected in month 6. Children's blood lead confirmed in month 17. State agency: "culture of minimization."
Post 5
Jackson, MS: 83% Black, 25% poverty. MSDH documents lead issues in 2015. Does not report. System violates federal standards repeatedly. 2020 consent order in place. 2022: 150,000 lose water. 2024 EPA OIG: seven years of hidden evidence confirmed.
The communities that bear the cost of the water machine are not randomly selected. They are the communities with the least political power to demand accountability from the institutions that are supposed to protect them. The Navajo Nation was excluded from the room in 1922. Flint's democratic governance was replaced by a cost-cutting mandate. Jackson's state oversight agency chose silence over reporting for seven years.
The machine is not a conspiracy. It does not require bad intentions to produce these outcomes — though the Flint Task Force's "culture of minimization" and MSDH's seven years of silence required choices made by specific individuals. It requires only that the institutions responsible for protection be accountable to constituencies other than the communities they are supposed to protect. And in every case in this series, they were.
✓ THE FULL ACCOUNT: WHAT JACKSON'S RECOVERY HAS PRODUCED
The water is now safe. As of early 2026, Jackson's water meets federal and Mississippi standards. JXN Water's quarterly reports show operational stability. No widespread crises since 2022. The system that failed catastrophically is functioning.
The infrastructure improvements are real. Leak detection and repair reduced system demand by 25–27%. Winterization of treatment plants — which prevented a repeat of the 2021 and 2022 failures during subsequent cold snaps. Corrosion control completed at one treatment plant, ongoing at the other. These are genuine, documented improvements.
The governance transition is proceeding. 2026 Mississippi legislation (H.B. 1677) creates a Metro Jackson Water Authority with a city majority on the board — addressing concerns about state takeover while providing regional governance structure. A transition plan is due by October 2026 per court order.
The honest accounting: Seven years of hidden evidence produced a catastrophic failure in 2022. The post-crisis intervention proved the system was fixable with proper management and accountability. The residents who went weeks without safe water in 2022 — in a majority-Black city that had been raising alarms for years — will not receive those weeks back. The EPA OIG report that confirmed what happened will not be unwritten. Both the progress and the permanent record of how the failure happened are now part of Jackson's documented history.
What Posts 4 and 5 Together Prove
Flint and Jackson are not the same story. The mechanisms differ: Flint was a one-time decision made by a specific emergency manager in 2014. Jackson was decades of deterioration accelerated by a state regulatory agency's systematic failure to report what it documented over seven years. The scale differs. The geography differs.
What they share is more important than what distinguishes them: both are majority-Black communities in which the institutional mechanism responsible for protecting public water failed, in documented ways, for documented periods of time, producing documented harm to documented populations — and the failure was not discovered by the institutions themselves. In Flint, it was a pediatrician and a Virginia Tech research team. In Jackson, it was a federal OIG investigation two years after the crisis.
The institutions that failed were not designed to fail. They were designed to protect. The gap between design and performance — in both cases — followed the same contours: the communities with the least political power to demand accountability received the least accountability from the institutions accountable to political power.
In Post 6, the series shifts from public failure to private extraction. Greenstone Resource Partners. 485 acres of Arizona farmland. $10 million purchase price. $24 million sale. $14 million profit. Zero infrastructure built. Zero water created. The first private sale of Colorado River water rights in history — approved by federal regulators, challenged by rural counties, and flowing to a Phoenix suburb right now.
METHODOLOGY — POST 5: All figures primary-sourced. EPA OIG Report (2024) — primary source for MSDH failure findings including 2015 lead documentation and failure to report; direct findings paraphrased per OIG report summary confirmed via EPA.gov OIG publications. Jackson demographics (83% Black, 25% poverty): confirmed via U.S. Census Bureau, 2020 American Community Survey. 2020 federal consent order: confirmed via EPA/DOJ press release, February 2020. 2022 crisis timeline: confirmed via contemporaneous AP, Reuters, and Mississippi Today reporting; Governor Reeves emergency declaration August 29-30, 2022 (confirmed). 150,000–180,000 residents affected: confirmed via multiple news sources and JXN Water reports. 50%+ non-revenue water loss: confirmed via JXN Water interim manager reports and Mississippi Today. Leak detection reducing demand 25–27%: confirmed via JXN Water quarterly progress reports (2023–2024). Ted Henifin appointment as ITPM: confirmed via federal court docket, Interim Stipulated Order, November 2022. JXN Water: confirmed via Jackson city records and court filings. H.B. 1677 (2026): confirmed via Mississippi Legislature records. Current water status meets standards: confirmed via JXN Water quarterly reports, early 2026. Winter storm 2021 failure: confirmed via contemporaneous reporting. Pearl River crest ~35 feet: confirmed via USGS and Mississippi Emergency Management Agency. Boil-water advisory lifted September 15, 2022: confirmed via JXN Water and City of Jackson official announcements.
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment